Wave Energy

Wave Energy is one of the niche renewable energy technologies which is still in its infancy stage. While other forms of alternative energy like solar, wind and biomass see hundreds of  billions of dollars in investment each year, wave energy does not see even $1 billion in investment. This is because Wave Energy is still much behind in the technology curve in terms of costs and reliability. Also there are many varied approaches and technologies to harness the power of the ocean waves.However developed countries like UK are promoting this renewable energy since it has huge potential like solar and wind energy.Given the energy shortages that we are facing, we need to promote all forms of sustainable green energy and wave energy definitely has strong promise. Here we present the various pros and cons of wave energy:

Pros of Wave Energy

  1. Minimal Greenhouse Gas Emissions/Air Pollution – Wave Energy does not produce any GHG emissions or cause air pollution from the combustion of fossil fuels unlike coal,oil or gas. This makes them very attractive as a source of cheap,non carbon dioxide producing electricity. Note Wave Energy does release some carbon dioxide when cold water reaches the upper surface of the ocean but the GHG emission from this is only 5% of what similar amounts of fossil fuel burning products so it can safely be ignored.
  2. No Fuel Cost – Waver Energy does not require any fuel like most other sources of energy.T his is a huge advantage over other fossil fuels whose costs are increasing at a drastic  rate every year. Electricity prices are increasingly rapidly in most parts of  the world much faster than general inflation. Wave Energy is powered by the waves of the ocean which are totally free just like Wind and Sunlight.
  3. No Pollution and Deaths – Wave Energy does not lead to pollution disasters like the BP Oil Spill and Coal Deaths which are directly related to Dirty Energy Production.
  4. Size Advantages – Wave Energy Generators can be installed in various sizes with as little as 1 MW. This is not possible for other energy forms which require a minimum large size such as Coal, Nuclear etc.

Cons of Wave Energy

  1. Immature Technology –  Wave Power is quite immature,costly and unproven in large scale. While some companies have made good progress, the technology remains largely unproven and has only been put to actual test in pilot cases. Some companies have gone out of business as their technology failed in actual field tests. The hazards of operating 24/7 in ocean conditions is not easy.
  2. Slow Technology Improvement – Wave  Energy has the potential to generate 100s of gigawatts of electricity through. However the technology improvement has been slow with setbacks. While Wave Energy has been known since the 1700s the progress has been extremely slow.
  3. Difficulty in Transmission of Wave Electricity – Wave Power generate power quite far away from the consumption of electricity. Transportation of Wave Energy can be quite cumbersome and expensive. Some Wave Energy Generators are converting power at the bottom of the ocean or far away from the shoreline. Moving that power towards where it is used can be difficult.
  4. Weather Effects – Severe Weather like Storms and Typhoons can be quite devastating on the Wave Power Equipment especially those place on the Sea Floor.
  5. Intermittent Nature – One of the biggest problems of Renewable Power is that it is intermittent in nature as it generates energy only when there are waves. This problem can be solved with energy storage however this leads to additional costs.
  6. High Capital Investment – A Wave Power Plant can cost around$6-10 million million to be spent in building 1 Megawatt.
  7.  Loss of Scenery – The sight of wave generators around the shoreline can look quite ugly and cause loss of tourism potential around shorelines. Also local residents can have problems even with wave power equipment which is not far offshore. The Cape Wind Energy project off the shore of Massachusetts has been delayed by over 10 years as it has drawn serious objections from the owners of coastal homes about loss in their property values.
  8. Cannot be Built Anywhere – This is a disadvantage which is common to all  the 3 types of Water based Energy that is Tidal, Hydro and Waver Energy. Some forms of Energy are just better suited to some places. For example you can’t build a nuclear plant on top of an earthquake prone region, you can’t build a wind farm near the Dead Sea etc. Hydro Energy can only be built in particular places though enough of those places exist globally. There are areas like the Pacific Northwest which are more suited to this form of energy.

Also read about other forms of Water based EnergyAdvantages and Disadvantages of Tidal Energy.

Other Interesting Reads

  1. Pros and Cons of Wind Power,Turbines and Farms – The Advantages outweighs the Disadvantages
  2. Ten Advantages of Biomass Energy – Oldest Alternative Energy Form gets back in vogue
  3. Is Algae Based Biofuel a Great Green Investment Opportunity
  4. Advantages of Solar Energy – Declining Cost the Biggest One

The Government on India is proposing to introduce mandatory blending of ethanol in transport fuels to the extend of 5%.This means that the major transport fuel providers like IOC,BPCL and other will have to ensure that 5% of the petrol they sell will be mixed with 5% ethanol.The US is the biggest user of mandatory blending which has recently come under harsh criticism.The reasons given for supporting blending is that it reduces the requirements of fossil fuels which leads to lower carbon emissions,improves energy security and reduces pollution.However none of these advantages are seen in real life.In fact it has the massively negative consequence of increasing food prices which leads to the starvation of the poor globally.The Corn Industry in the USA has become a major lobbying force which makes the US government persist with the policy resulting in sharp increase in corn prices to the detriment of consumers.

India’s Economic Advisory Council too has questioned the wisdom of ethanol blending saying the proposal would work only if there was adequate supply of ethanol.The sugar industry says there is enough ethanol while the advisory council says its not.The facts seem to suggest that the shortfall will be around 40-50% leading to huge windfall gains for the Sugar Industry.My view is that the government should wait for advancements in third generation biofuels before subsidizing and supporting blending of ethanol in transport fuels.Already algae based biofuel startups like Solazyme are making good progress in commercializing fuels from materials which do not endanger global food security.

Biofuels from Crops – Bad Solution to Climate Change

Biofuels from Crops can never be  a meaningful answer to the problems of Climate Change and Global Warming due to the fact that

  1. A large part of the world’s 6 billion population lives in hunger
  2. Water and Land needed for Crops are becoming a Scarce Resource as per capita consumption and population both rise
  3. Inevitable Increase in Crop Prices increases the Raw Material prices
  4. Growing Demand for Biofuels lead to deforestation perversely contributing to Global Warming

USA Renewable Fuels Standards (RFS)

The Energy Policy Act of 2005 (EPAct 2005, P.L. 110-58), established the first-ever Renewable Fuels Standard (RFS) in federal law, requiring increasing volumes of ethanol and biodiesel to be blended with the U.S. fuel supply between 2006 and 2012.The Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007 (P.L. 110-140, H.R. 6) amended and increased the RFS, requiring 9 billion gallons of renewable fuel use in 2008, stepping up to 36 billion gallons by 2022.The US (EPA) has approved the sale of 15% ethanol fuel blends (E-15), an action that US energy officials immediately criticized as a bad policy meant to curry favour with voters.

Note USA is a huge food surplus country with massive quantities of corn being produced every year which makes it feasible for it to implement a dumb policy,however India does not possess such agricultural riches to implement mandatory blending of biofuels.

C Rangarajan questions the rationale behind Ethanol Blending Plan

The Prime Minister’s Economic Advisory Council has questioned the rationale behind mandatory doping of 5% ethanol in petrol, saying there is “a mismatch” between the objectives cited for pushing the programme and the empirical evidence supporting them. The council, headed by former Reserve Bank of India governor C Rangarajan , has asked the government to reconsider the programme or at least not make it binding for now.

The ministry had argued that mixing of ethanol in petrol was an environment-friendly initiative, which would save the country foreign exchange, provide energy security and benefit the sugar industry. Experts, however, said the proposal would work only if there was adequate supply of ethanol, opinion on which is divided. The chemicals and alcohol industry says there is not enough ethanol for everyone and it would be forced to import if ethanol was diverted for blending. Tamil Nadu has already banned supply to the ethanol blending programme and Bihar is understood to have “unofficially” discouraged it.

A government constituted panel, headed by Planning Commission member Saumitra Chaudhuri, has also questioned ethanol availability. Chaudhuri is also a member of the Economic Advisory Council. However, five of the eight members of the Chaudhuri panel had opposed sectoral allocation of ethanol, including to the ethanol blending programme. The council has also opposed direct ethanol manufacture from sugarcane on account of food security concerns. Ethanol is currently produced as a byproduct of sugar manufacturing.

Poland resiting EU mandate to shift from Dirty Coal to Green Energy Sources

Poland is one of the largest countries in Europe to have such a high dependence on Coal Energy to meet its Electricity Needs.Note European Union has a target to meet 20% of its Energy by 2020 from Renewable Energy sources which has mad the fossil fuel dependent Eastern European countries looks towards Wind,Solar and Biomass Energy.Note Eastern European countries like Romania have seen a boom in wind energy driven by incorrect Green Energy subsidy policies while the Solar Boom in Czech led to a drastic increase in electricity prices forcing the government to Bust it with a combination of FIT cuts,tax increases and strict regulation.Poland which is the largest Eastern European country in the EU has traditionally depended on Coal to meet most of its Energy Needs.Despite the major disadvantages of Coal,Poland has resisted reducing the support given to the Thermal Power Industry.The cheapness and abundance of Coal has made it hard for Poland to shift its Energy Policy like other Coal dependent nations like South Africa,China and India.

Poland Renewable Energy Target

Poland  has established a target of 7.5 percent of energy production from renewable sources by 2010, and 15% by 2020.  However, these targets have not yet been enforced, discouraging large scale renewable development.  Even so, the aggressive targets combined with strong economic growth provide a healthy investment atmosphere for renewable energy developers.   Utilities are required to purchase electricity from renewable sources, although prices are not regulated by tariffs.The Energy Act of April 2007 states that all energy companies selling electricity to end users have to obtain and present a specified number of renewable energy certificates or pay a substitution charge.

Solid biomass had the highest share in renewable energy production in 2008. It amounted to nearly 87% of the total domestic production of energy from renewable sources. Liquid biofuels were the next largest carrier in primary energy production from renewable sources (5.4%), followed by water (3.4%), biogas (2.4%) and wind (1.3%). Heat pumps, geothermal energy, solar radiation and energy from municipal waste were less significant in the total balance.

Renewable Energy in Poland Increasing with Wind and Biomass Energy

Biomass and wind appear to be the most promising renewable energy resources for development in Poland, with an estimated potential of about 4,000 MW each.

Wind Energy in Poland

Poland also has some of the best documented wind resources in Central and Eastern Europe with areas reaching up to 1,000 W/m2 in power density. Poland has started to increase its Renewable Energy Industry with 460 MW of Wind Energy installed in 2010 .Poland is set to install around 500 MW of Wind Energy this Year.Poland had 1,005 MW of installed capacity for wind-generated power in the middle of 2010.

The Polish Wind Energy Association predicts very dynamic growth of installed capacity in the wind power sector, amounting to about 13 GW in 20203). The figure comprises almost 11 GW of onshore wind farms, 1.5 GW in offshore wind and 600 MW of small wind.

Biomass Energy in Poland

Thermal Power Plant are being  converted into a Biomass Power Plants because Biomass Energy has a number of advantages over Coal Energy.Both liquid and solid biomass are considered to be the main sources of renewable energy in Poland, for both electricity and thermal energy production.  Currently, biomass is mainly used as heat in small and medium scale boilers in industrial settings. Common fuel is wood pieces, sawdust, and wood shavings. Combined heat and power (CHP) plants using organic waste from pulp and paper operations, and straw and wood fired heating plants are also in operation.

The amount of electricity generated from biomass between 2006 and 2008 increased nearly twofold – from 1818 GWh to 3267 GWh. A large part of it was generated in co-combustion processes (84% in 2008). Also the amount of electricity produced from biogas increased almost twice during the three analysed years, from 117 GWh in 2006 to 221 GWh in 2008. Over half of this was generated from landfill biogas (63% in 2008), one third from biogas produced in sewage treatment facilities and the remaining small part was generated in the agricultural sector (4% in 2008).

French energy company GDF-Suez plans to convert a 225 MW Coal powered Plant will be converted into a biomass powered plant making it one of the biggest biomass plants in the world,The 205 MW Biomass power plant in Polaniec, south-eastern Poland will use about 1 million tonnes of biomass a year.GDF is also interested in purchasing assets from Sweden’s Vattenfall. The latter company intends to leave the Polish market by selling its major holdings there.Poland’s second-largest utility, Tauron, has taken a z?.30 million loan to help it finance the conversion of its coal-fired power plant in Tychy so that it can burn biomass instead.Note Pure Play Biomass Companies are difficult to invest in as Biomass Power Plants are built by the utilities.

Electricity in Poland

Polish power generation system is the largest in Central and Eastern Europe in terms of capacity.Poland has around 3 GW of Total Electricity Capacity with 90% coming form Thermal Power .It also has around 2 GW of Renewable Energy Capacity. Household electricity prices have increased by 32% since 2004, but they remain about 14% below the EU-15 and  EU-25 averages. Prices for industrial customers are about 28% below the European averages The power system is very fragmented, with nearly 400 power plants.Solar and Hydro Energy Resources in not well developed in Poland though a few companies have started to manufacture solar energy products in the country.

More Links on Poland Energy

1) http://www.elektrownie-wiatrowe.org.pl/en/

2) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_power_in_Poland

3) http://www.enercee.net/poland/energy-sources.html

4) http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=Poland_and_coal

5) http://www.iea.org/stats/electricitydata.asp?COUNTRY_CODE=PL

Total the French Oil and Gas Giant has agreed to acquire 60% of the 2nd largest US Solar Energy Company Sunpower of $1.38 billion besides providing it another billion dollars in easy credit for its system business.Note M&A in the Solar Energy Industry has picked up with Korean Chaebol buying up Solarfun and recently Meyer Burger buying Roth & Rau to create the 2nd largest solar equipment producer in the world.Note competition in the solar energy industry has become fierce with the entry of a number of top MNC conglomerates besides a number of thin film startups.Coupled with the decline in European solar subsidies,the situation of high cost solar panel companies has become extremely difficult.Evergreen Solar a small US producer of  solar panels using ribbon technology is facing a cash crunch as its sales have plummeted.Other US and European companies too face difficult times after a stellar 2010 saved many a solar company from bankruptcy.

Big Oil and Gas Companies like Shell and BP have lost marketshare and reduced investments

Note Big Oil and Gas has been slowly been retrenching form the solar energy industry despite initial leadership.Shell which was one of the biggest solar players has become almost non-existent while BP has shut down a number of solar factories outsourcing production to China.BP Solar is still one of the to players in the industry despite falling down the rankings rapidly from a top 10 position 2-3 years ago.Shell has also sold of most of its technology and manufacturing to other companies .Other Oil and Gas companies like Exxon,Valero,Chevron and others have concentrated their energies on related green sectors like algae based biofuels rather than on solar and wind energy.So the move by Total comes as a surprise as it acquires one of the top 15 solar panel companies in the world.Sunpower is being acquired at a cheap price considering its world beating solar cell technology and its massive systems business which has gigawatts of solar projects under development.Note Sunpower makes the highest efficiency solar panels on a commercial scale and recently tied up with AUO.It is the 2nd biggest solar plant installer in the US and has a massive presence in the commercial and government sector.Total said it looked at over 200 companies before buying Sunpower.Note M&A has been strong in the Solar Thermal Industry and has now started picking up in the Solar PV Industry as well.With solar company valuations at a historic low,it makes sense for the larger chemical and energy companies to pick up good companies on the cheap.

Total SA, Europe’s third-biggest oil producer, agreed to buy as much as 60 percent of SunPower Corp. for $1.38 billion, taking advantage of increased global interest in renewable energy.

SunPower, the second-largest U.S. solar panel maker, described the acquisition price of $23.25 a share as a “friendly tender offer” in a statement yesterday after the close of regular trading. SunPower surged $6.08, or 38 percent, to $22.20 at 9:32 a.m. on the Nasdaq Stock Market.The deal for San Jose, California-based SunPower may lead to more solar industry acquisitions as U.S. and European suppliers seek help competing against rival suppliers in Asia, said Kevin Landis, portfolio manager at Sivest Group Inc.“This is exactly what SunPower needed to compete with the Chinese manufacturers that are getting so much support from their government,” Landis said in an interview. “It also allows SunPower to double down on the technology improvements they’ll need to compete in the long run.”Total will also provide SunPower with as much as $1 billion of credit support over the next five years.

Evergreen Solar Warns Of Slowing Demand, Liquidity Woes; Shares Off

Evergreen Solar Inc. (ESLR) said uncertainties about subsidies programs have substantially slowed demand for solar panels this year, a trend that has extended beyond the historically sluggish first quarter.As a result, the solar company said its near-term liquidity has been hurt and it may have to secure additional sources of cash sooner than expected. Evergreen said it will continue to restructure its existing debt.Chief Executive Michael El-Hillow warned the longer-than-expected slowdown, combined with worldwide capacity expansion, has led to a significant increase in solar panel inventory.”While we believe the market for solar panels will continue to show good long-term growth, the near term remains uncertain and we will adjust our production in Wuhan to make certain we can match the market’s demands and at the same time improve our cash-to-cash cycles,” he said.

Type of Renewable Energy have been increasing with development in Technology and the imperative of using Alternative Energy as Fossil Fuels deplete and increase in costs. Besides Global Warming has made the benefits of Renewable Energy seem more attractive with each passing year. Note though there are many niches Renewable Energy types, the Three Major Forms of Renewable Energy are Solar Energy,Wind Energy and Biomass Energy (Biofuels).

Nuclear and Hydro Energy are not considered  as Renewable Energy according to the strict definition of Renewable Energy. However Hydro and Nuclear Energy both are responsible for more than 15% of global electricity production each. The clean energy industry saw a 30% increase in investments to $243 billion in 2010 which was another record year for Renewable Energy Capacity addition. Around 18 GW of Solar Energy and 38 GW of Wind Energy were installed with Solar Energy Capacity increasing by a whopping 150% from 2009. Wind power continued to lead at $95 billion. The solar sector is experiencing significant growth, with investments growing at 53% to $79 billion (source Pew).

Each Type of Renewable Energy has Advantages and Disadvantages which are specific to that type of Alternative Energy. For example Solar and Wind are intermittent in nature while Geothermal Energy has no such problems however Geothermal Energy suffers from a lack of good sites and takes a long time to get installed.

Main Types of Renewable Energy

Solar Energy

Solar Power has been the fastest growing energy source in the last decade showing a compounded annual growth of over 50%. In 2010 alone, solar energy demand grew by almost 150% beating the most optimistic forecasts as costs kept on declining for this renewable energy source. While Solar Power continues to be one of the most expensive forms of energy, it is also the energy source where the costs are declining rapidly. With solar costs going down by another 10% each year over the next few years, expect Solar Energy to grow at a further fast rate in the future as well after growing at 50% CAGR over the last decade.

Wind Energy

Wind Power has become the biggest source of renewable energy in the world after Nuclear and Hydro Energy (if you consider Nuclear/Hydro to be renewable energy that is). The reason for the huge increase in wind energy has been the sharply falling costs which have roughly become equivalent to Gas fired Energy. While Solar Energy costs are still falling, they are still way above the costs of fossil fuel energy. Wind Energy unlike other forms of fossil fuel energy should have much  less opposition however it is not so. Unlike Coal, Gas and Oil Energy it does not lead to increase in Greenhouse Gas Emissions and contribute to pollution. It does not lead to deaths of hundreds of miners each year nor has the danger of a catastrophic nuclear meltdown leading to death and disability of thousands. It also does not have the drawback of  massive ocean pollution leading to an ecological disaster.

Biomass Energy

Biomass Energy is the oldest source of Energy known to mankind and till the 19th century was the primary energy source. Even now Biomass Energy is used of Heating and Cooking by a large percentage of the Human Population. Biomass Energy with improving technology is being now used to construct large biomass power plants. Growing Concerns over Climate Change and soaring Coal Prices are making some Power Plants convert from Coal to Biomass as a Fuel Source. Biomass Energy has many advantages such as being Carbon Neutral, using Animal and Crop Wastes in a useful manner, being poor friendly etc. However Biomass Energy like other Renewable Energy forms of Geothermal Energy faces problems of resources.

Quasi Renewable Energy Forms

Hydro Energy

Hydroelectricity is one of the largest sources of energy accounting for roughly 20% of the worldwide demand of electricity with around 800 GW of capacity installed. There is considerable potential still left and developing countries like India and China can be expected to install another 500 GW over the coming years. Hydroelectricity is very important as it does not lead to GHG emissions and contribute to global warming. It also does not have the drawbacks like other renewable energy forms of high costs and intermittency. The advantages of hydroelectricity are substantial enough to far outweigh any disadvantages. But like nuclear energy, hydro power has some tail risks which can lead to catastrophic damage.

Nuclear Energy

Nuclear Power has come under assault in the aftermath of the Fukushima Nuclear Accident with Nuclear becoming a four letter word. However Nuclear Energy cannot be ignored because its benefits are unique in some applications and cannot be substituted by any other means. Nuclear Power also cannot be replaced in the short term from its most widely used application of generating Electricity. Note Nuclear Power accounts for almost 15% of the Global Electricity and in some countries is the major source of energy. For example France which has 80% of its power coming from Nuclear Fission, its impossible to think of shutting down nuclear plants like Germany which gets around 20%. Nuclear Energy has almost infinite potential but if you apply a strict definition, it is not exactly renewable in the sense that uranium fuel once used cannot be renewed to be usable again.

Minor Renewable Energy Forms

Geothermal Energy

Geothermal Energy is regarded as a poor cousin to its more glamorous cousins Wind and Solar. Geothermal Energy Capacity has been installed and the growth rate is a pathetic 3-4% compared to the over 50% CAGR seen for solar energy and around 30% for Wind Energy. However Geothermal Energy possesses one attribute that the others do not. Its 24 hour generation capability is a massive plus compared to the intermittent nature of Wind and Solar Energy. However long project development time and large capital investments have deterred fast growth in geothermal energy in the world. However some countries like Iceland, Indonesia, Philippines and USA have a strong geothermal energy industry.

Tidal Energy

Tidal Energy is a niche form of Renewable Energy with less than 500 MW of Electricity Capacity worldwide. Tidal Energy generates less than .001% of the worldwide electricity generation as the Technology of this Alternative Energy is still quite immature. However numerous companies are researching ways to develop Tidal Energy as it offers almost unlimited potential at low costs and with no pollution. Tidal Wave Energy has not seen much commercial success except the almost 45 year old Tidal Wave Power Plant in France.

Wave Energy

Like Tidal Energy, Wave Energy is another niche Clean Energy Source. Waves are caused by the wind blowing over the surface of the ocean. In many areas of the world, the wind blows with enough consistency and force to provide continuous waves. There is tremendous energy in the ocean waves. Wave power devices extract energy directly from the surface motion of ocean waves or from pressure fluctuations below the surface. Wave power varies considerably in different parts of the world, and wave energy can’t be harnessed effectively everywhere. Wave-power rich areas of the world include the western coasts of Scotland, northern Canada, southern Africa, Australia, and the northwestern coasts of the United States.

Summary

Besides the above mentioned Renewable Energy sources there are other clean energy forms like Fuel Cells which are not exactly Renewable Energy but come under the Clean Energy Category. Waste Energy or Energy from Methane comes under the broad heading of Biomass Energy which also encompasses Biofuel from Celluloid and non-Celluloid Sources.

Best of GWI

Alternative Energy/Clean Technology/Climate Change

Solar Energy

Tidal Energy

Nuclear Energy

Wind Energy

Biomass Energy/Biofuels

Hydro Energy

List of World’s Largest Hydroelectricity Plants and Countries – China Leading in building Hydroelectric Stations

Green Stocks

India Investing

Income Disparity,Unemployment,Inequality

Corruption in India

World Economy/Markets

Clean Technology in USA

Clean Technology in Germany

Renewable Energy in China

Renewable Energy in India

Initial Public Offerings (IPO)

Technology